Which would you say be a better game to play?

I would have to go with Godfather 2

godfather 2 have good features, but the mafia have awesome story.

so I can't decide which one.

Im opinion, Godfather 2.

Mafia 2 has no autosave feature, and when you're done with the missions, there isnt much to do except make a new game.

Godfather on the other hand, you can hand-pick the crew you'd like to be part of. Also has other features, like "The Don's View" and has multiplayer. :)

Godfather2.

Mafia was 2 easy and not much to do.

Agreed I liked Mafia 2 was a great game but Godfather 2 had like so much more features which I liked.

Mafia 2 because godfather 2 when i finsh i never played it again now mafia 2 i beat it and ill still like to play. Mafia 2 joe adventure ius coming out later

Mafia2 all the way

Mafia 2....beat that game in 11 hours.

Mafia 2, i love the game play.

MAfia 2

It's a tough question. They're both good in their own reasons.

Godfather 2 has great features while Mafia2 hasn't got shit. Though I like The storyline on Mafia 2 much better. I don't like the way they make stuff look too easy though. For example, the second chapter. I doubt a phone call would have gotten Vito out of the army in a matter of what, 45 seconds?

Also, Joe, I've got a question - You say they are going to be making a Mafia 2 about Joe's story? How so if he died at the end of the game?

All in all, I'd pick Mafia 2.

Vito was in prison for about six of so years - Joe's Adventure takes place during that time.

Oh, that's seems pretty cool.

Let's just hope I can get a copy before Gamefly runs out!

Godfather 2 and heres why.

Mafia 1 & 2 had always portrayed a story that was somewhat against rising up the ranks of the hierachy.

GF2 however was designed so you could actually rise and become don, plus imo gameplay was better in gf2 especially gf1, I actually found gf1 harder than gf 2, taking hubs down on your own was a challenge :)

Mafia 2 had great story but it lacked other things to make it really great.