I never played mafia 2 and I wonder if its worth getting

Mafia 2 is good. definitely worth buying. But GTA 4 is better than alot of other games. But I spek for the 260. idk about pc or ps3

I wasnt big fan of mafia 2 waited so long for it since first 1 and it didnt last very long was disappointed.

Mafia 2, has a better story but i finished it in a day :/ gta iv takes a bit longer

do not buy mafia 2. It's not "free roam" like you experience in GTA.

Mafia 2 does have a world, but its not like you can decide to go fuck off and do other shit, you have to follow the missions. Rent it and beat it in a day or two...its only good for the story line

Personally I prefer GTA but that's just me :)

you can free roam in Mafia 2. but once you beat the game it ends, no continued play, but it lasts only about a day,

both of that games are really good but i prefer more mafia 2

GTA 4 More freedom and it's longer Mafia 2 is more for renting since its shorter but it has an intersting story.

To answer your question, GTA all the way, but Mafia 2 for rent or borrow. Maybe buy if it's in the 20$ box.

Mafia 2!

MAfia 2

Mafia 2, hands down.

Youre all crazy. GTA4 is a much better game. Mafia 2 is good only for the storyline (very short)

I agree with doog. Both good, but mafia 2 is only good for storylines unless you want to waste $20 on DLC.

GTA 4

Everyone saying Mafia 2 is better is just saying it because it has 'Mafia' in the name or they want to sound different.

i beat mafia way too fast but it was just way better gameplay and controls and such so my vote MAFIA 2 ps im yet to beat gta4 cuz it bores me

hmm i have to give that to mafia 2 really i say the story was way better but was alittle short i kinda hated how it ended  gta 4 was longer but the story was all choppy

mafia 2

I think mafia 2 was too short of story so I have to go with GTA 4.