Pretty simple...

When ideas get enough votes to be put through to the Player Commission, they are deleted from the suggestions forum as it's making it very hard to keep up with all the suggestions with so many "sticky" threads at the top.

Yes please!

The idea behind it was so that people could still add to the discussion if they wanted to after it went to the PC Forum.

I'm not sure how well that is working at the moment and if users would prefer not to have those threads stickied, I don't see any problem with them not being so.

If the suggestions make it through to the game, they're not suggestions anymore...they're IN. What's the point in spamming up the Suggestions forum with 'em?

{I believe that this has more to do with how many we as the PC are sponsoring before we are actually completing other suggestions. Is there anyway we can limit how many can be sponsored vs how many are still in discussion/voting?}

{We could scale it back a touch if necessary, but the debate is hardly thriving in the Player Commission forum and that greatly limits the speed at which each suggestion can be brought to fruition.}

{The suggestions aren't going anywhere. They will still be there when we get through the ones we get pushed through. Hell there are suggestions from years ago that we haven't even delved into, that maybe deserve more priority than current suggestions we are sponsoring just because they are right in front of us. Maybe we could have a mixture of past and present at a time that we sponsor and get cleared up, hopefully as quickly as possible so that new ones may be given the same attention.}

{I've thought about this as well. I'm not sure whether to go back historically or deal with suggestions as and when they arise. I think it might be worth saying to users that have made/seen a valid suggestion to bump it back to the top.

I don't really fancy waiting weeks and months between sponsoring suggestions though to see the few that have enough sponsors get through the PC. I think that will discourage people with the PC process.}

{I'm not saying weeks and months between sponsoring, as I don't think we should be taking weeks and months to finish processing suggestions that have been sponsored. And as soon as one is out the door another can certainly take it's place. I'm really just trying to get us to keep the process going, instead of sponsoring 8 suggestions, not doing diddly with them when they get sponsored, but continuing to sponsor other suggestions.}

Anyone else just getting a load of black boxes show up on people's posts here? :o

http://www.mehwhatever.com/profile/pics/blackbox.png

^ screenshot of what I see

Redacted Text

• Both forums have redacted text.
• Redacted text may only be read by Player Commision Members. (and admins of course)
• To everyone else the redacted text will be displayed as black bars.

Gotcha! Cheers.

Those are enkindle's words by the way, not mine, from his "Player Commission - How it works" Thread.

{To me that is basically saying, all other suggestions are not valid because the suggestor is dead. I don't really believe that theory either. I don't mind discussing suggestions as they come in, but other people that don't play anymore have made valid suggestions in the past that I think are just as important as current ones.}

Sounds like a decent compromise to me, enkindle. I'd be happy with them just having "sticky" off.

{So what? Because the people who originally suggested it will wonder why it was sponsored then not done shit with. I'd rather it sit in suggestions unsponsored than we sponsor it and leave it to just sit and do nothing, then it really looks like we're not doing our jobs, which they are already complaining about. The point of sponsoring them is to get them through the process. I'd rather not have 20 sitting in the queue waiting to be discussed and voted on. I'd rather have minimal, get them done and through so that more can be given the same time and attention.}