I have played both but can't decide which is better. I like the blood spattering on cod 5 and i also like seeing limbs flying off when the enemies die. But the cod 4 wepeons are better than the cod 5 one's.

But my question to you is which one is better?

I havent played call of duty before to be honest. but it would be interesting to see what people think

I use to play cod4 competitively and cod4 is def better. cod5 is a childrens game meant for casual gamers

cod5 has nazi zombie but the weapons suck cod4 has better weapons so i think cod4 is bettter

COD duh the only thing good about COD5 is natzi zombi

I think COD 5 I enjoy using old weapons, dont get me wrong new wepaons are sick as, but the old ones have a speacial thing about them.

Cod4 is just tooo sick

COD4 is better, but the new one needs zombie terrorists mode or something

I personally like CoD4 better as I like the more modern day fighting. I wasn't too interested in another world war game, but I did play it and it isn't that bad. Just me more preferring the newer modern fighting styles and weapons.

Yeah! There have been too many war games all trying to out sell each other. It's kinda sad that they can't come up with anything different. But i think the R.U.S.E. should be a good game and i am deffinately gonna buy it off xbox live.

R.U.S.E trailer was pretty cool. U guys should watch it. But seriously though, CoD4 is better. Too much WW2 FPS. But Mordern Warefare? Not entirely new concept, but it's fresher

COD4 is better online than CODWAW. I don't like the addition of vehicles tbh.

I like COD 5 because of everything you said but i also like the tommy gun.