This is really an age old question but here goes anyway..

I prefer Chocolate, what about you?

chocolate hands down

Got to be Chocolate!

Swirl is the best of both worlds. Rox, I strongly urge you to break those barriers and next time your at the ice-cream machine or getting a milkshake - Throw caution to the wind and mix them together!

choco yum yum

I generally go with vanilla.

I prefer Chocolateand i have to have strawberrys with it they are great together yummy

No No NO Diva I said Strawberry is not an Opt! Umm Alfonce if you mix Vanilla and chocolate together don't you still just end up with a lighter Chocolate? just wondering because I never actually tried a milkshake that way,

Well it only said Strawberry wasnt an option so Im going with butterscotch it goes well with those gay ass cheap chocolate easter bunnies they sell around this time of year. 

Triple swirl is the best. Pink, blue, yellow. Such pretty colours!

... until it all gets mixed together and turns a peculiar shade of green.

chocalate hands down. Claudio_Delucci

If there is strictly no deviation... then I'm with Shamroc.  Vanilla, hands down the old standby.

vanilla for sure!!

Hmm. Surprise me!

Theresa, try dipping those gay-ass cheap chocolate bunnies in some peanut butter, zomg!

PEANUT BUTTER? Hmm will have to try it.. I shall go pick up another gay ass bunny to try that with. Thank you Joy_Turner

I prefer the ice cream maker. 

i have to agree with shamroc and armorist i prefer vanilla theres just so much you can do with vanilla think sundeas - bananna splits - the magic shell stuff that hardens yummy

i change mine forget chocolate the best ice cream is peanut butter and peanut butter milkshakes are the best

Neopolitan. I win.

Vanilla.