Personally, my order would be this:

A) Unproed BG, in same city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
C) Unproed BG, in other city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
B) Unproed BG, in same city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
D) Unproed BG, in other city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
E) Proed BG, in same city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
G) Proed BG, in other city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
F) Proed BG, in same city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
H) Proed BG, in other city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)

Hope this helps!

A) Unproed BG, in same city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
C) Unproed BG, in other city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
B) Unproed BG, in same city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
D) Unproed BG, in other city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
E) Proed BG, in same city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
G) Proed BG, in other city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
F) Proed BG, in same city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
H) Proed BG, in other city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)

Seeing as some people prefer B to C while others would rather get C than B, why not group some of the options together?

So:
1. A
2. B & C (you get both, you can choose what suits you best)
3. D & E
4. F & G
5. H

A) Unproed BG, in same city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
C) Unproed BG, in other city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
B) Unproed BG, in same city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
D) Unproed BG, in other city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
E) Proed BG, in same city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
G) Proed BG, in other city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
F) Proed BG, in same city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
H) Proed BG, in other city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)

Glad this is being looked at. I hate paying for a BG tip and the BG given is Pro'd while there are others out there.

Also appreciate you asking for user input.

Everyone is glad you followed the rules PerpetuumMobile.

A) Unproed BG, in same city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
C) Unproed BG, in other city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
B) Unproed BG, in same city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
D) Unproed BG, in other city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
E) Proed BG, in same city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
G) Proed BG, in other city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
F) Proed BG, in same city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
H) Proed BG, in other city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)

A) Unproed BG, in same city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)

C) Unproed BG, in other city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
B) Unproed BG, in same city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)

D) Unproed BG, in other city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
E) Proed BG, in same city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
F) Proed BG, in same city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
G) Proed BG, in other city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
H) Proed BG, in other city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)

I can see a trend already :)

A) Unproed BG, in same city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
C) Unproed BG, in other city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
B) Unproed BG, in same city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
D) Unproed BG, in other city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
E) Proed BG, in same city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
G) Proed BG, in other city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
F) Proed BG, in same city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
H) Proed BG, in other city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)

Just to echo sentiments already made, good job on asking the masses thier preference :)

A) Unproed BG, in same city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
C) Unproed BG, in other city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
B) Unproed BG, in same city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
D) Unproed BG, in other city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)

I'd personally never like to pay half a credit to learn about a protected BG

A) Unproed BG, in same city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
C) Unproed BG, in other city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
B) Unproed BG, in same city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
D) Unproed BG, in other city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
E) Proed BG, in same city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
G) Proed BG, in other city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
F) Proed BG, in same city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
H) Proed BG, in other city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)

A) Unproed BG, in same city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
C) Unproed BG, in other city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
B) Unproed BG, in same city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
D) Unproed BG, in other city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
E) Proed BG, in same city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
G) Proed BG, in other city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
F) Proed BG, in same city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
H) Proed BG, in other city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)

i like others prefer not to pay for protected bg info, but you wanted an order.  shame a pro time can't come with the tip for pro'd bgs.

A) Unproed BG, in same city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
C) Unproed BG, in other city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
B) Unproed BG, in same city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
D) Unproed BG, in other city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
E) Proed BG, in same city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
G) Proed BG, in other city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
F) Proed BG, in same city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
H) Proed BG, in other city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)

A) Unproed BG, in same city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
C) Unproed BG, in other city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
B) Unproed BG, in same city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
D) Unproed BG, in other city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
E) Proed BG, in same city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
G) Proed BG, in other city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
F) Proed BG, in same city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
H) Proed BG, in other city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)

Like beachbum said. If I have paid a tip and get a pro'd bg I would like the pro time.

Do not eliminate the pro'd bgs, if that is all that is left then... that's whats left.

A) Unproed BG, in same city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
C) Unproed BG, in other city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
B) Unproed BG, in same city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
D) Unproed BG, in other city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
E) Proed BG, in same city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
G) Proed BG, in other city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
F) Proed BG, in same city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
H) Proed BG, in other city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)

Like others have said, would be good to know the pro time if possible (possibly for paying additional cash if need be)

A) Unproed BG, in same city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
C) Unproed BG, in other city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
B) Unproed BG, in same city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
D) Unproed BG, in other city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
E) Proed BG, in same city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
G) Proed BG, in other city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
F) Proed BG, in same city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
H) Proed BG, in other city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)

Echo the sentiments of BeachBum also.

A) Unproed BG, in same city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
C) Unproed BG, in other city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
B) Unproed BG, in same city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
D) Unproed BG, in other city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
E) Proed BG, in same city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
G) Proed BG, in other city (Any BGs eliminated where success would be under 50% based)
F) Proed BG, in same city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)
H) Proed BG, in other city (No rank filtered, chance of getting bgs out of your range)

Much like most.. this is my preferred. However I have gone for the approach that helps majority of the site who don't train their guns which is what quite a few people have said too.

One thing I'd like to throw in is the fact.. I personally don't think that it should give you a proed BG if you pay .5 of a credit. As after all.. we pay .5 a credit to get a shot of.. not to be told its proed.