Get Timers Now!
X
 
Sep 21 - 18:20:21
-1
Game Suggestions
0 Watchers
Page: [ <<< - < ] 1 2 3 
HQ Threads, Made + only option Started by: Sandor on Sep 06, '12 02:50

I have been watching the PC Thread on this suggestion, a suggestion which I had thought prior would not need that much discussion. I can see now that I was wrong, all because of another suggestion that seems to overlap this one. The suggestion that Right and Left hands be Made+.

I have also seen that Sandor, the person that made this excellent suggestion, has taken back the part about the HQ Threads being seen by Right and Left hands. That could easily be addressed in that other suggestion. Its sad that one of the best suggestions I have seen, might get way-layed by this other problem.

Furthermore, and I am not trying to ruffle any feathers by saying this, but are the PC Crew not supposed to look at things from an un-bias perspective, for the good of the game, and not from the perspective of someone who might lose privaleges because of the position they hold in the game?

I can understand why someone would want to give their friend, whom they trust, a Right or Left hand spot in their Crew, but I do not agree with having the same people always getting the same spots because of friendship, when that was not how the game was designed, unless I am completely missing the point here. 

It seems ranks are meaningless, unless you are IWP with a good gun. Do not let this suggestion lose ground because of a rank that can be obtained in 11 days.

Report Post Tip

Are the PC not considering the objective implications of this suggestion? I haven't seen anyone being subjective about it.

If the suggestion does not pass a vote in it's current form, I will likely suggest another vote with Sandor's amendment.

Report Post Tip

Furthermore, and I am not trying to ruffle any feathers by saying this, but are the PC Crew not supposed to look at things from an un-bias perspective, for the good of the game, and not from the perspective of someone who might lose privaleges because of the position they hold in the game?



Id like to state that I see none of the PC members viewing or commenting on this in the manner suggested.

The debate with regard to hands stemmed from the original suggestion, which Sandor has explained he now sees no need for. It would seem to me that most others agreed with the idea in principal and so I would hope to see voting commence on its current form.

Report Post Tip

Can't wait to see this implemented! Will come in handy for that extra information.

Eric pats Sandor on the head. He then looks over at PC-Grin

VOTE VOTE VOTE!

Report Post Tip

Joins in the chant...

VOTE VOTE VOTE!

chuckles

Report Post Tip
The voting for this suggestion has passed.

PC-ralph has voted YES. [3] (Good idea. However, having RH/LH view all material in their own HQ seems practical as they represent their leader - regardless of rank.)
PC-Asylum has voted YES. [1] (No reason given)
PC-Flash-Fire has voted YES. [1] (Great idea, RH/LH are trusted positions more so than made man.)
PC-Patti has voted YES. [1] (I like the idea regardless of the rh/lh rank. I figure if the CL is so concerned with who sees the forum, and his rh isn\'t of rank, he/she probably won\'t use it much. So it doesn\'t hurt to have it. :))
PC-Pratster has voted YES. [1] (a RH and LH of a family should have access regardless to their rank. Sometimes the CL is in no position to give a Made+ member RH/LH. This shouldn\'t then punish them further by their right hands being unable to view.)
PC-Squishy has voted YES. [1] (Anything to further promote that mademan+ is important is good.)
PC-Tech has voted YES. [1] (The RHM/LHM could probably sleep in the same bed as the leader.)
PC-Grin has voted NO. [4] (I like the idea, but I don\'t like RHM/LHM having access unless they are also ranked Made Man or above)
PC-Cassiopeia has voted NO. [1] (I like this suggestion, however I do not support hands being able to view the forum regardless of rank. If it\'s a Made+ forum then it needs to stay that.)
PC-Ter has voted NO. [1] (Love the idea other then the - RHM/LHM regardless of rank bit.)
PC-Warrior has voted NO. [1] (Made Man+ is a good idea. I dont feel the need to make allowances for people that have chosen a below rank RH/LH (something ive done myself often))
PC-El_Nino has not voted. [2]
PC-Sayyid has not voted. [1]

Voting Totals, Yes: 9 (7), No: 7 (4), Undecided: 3 (2).

PC-Pratster, it is now your responsibility to write a final summary for the coders and to create/edit the wiki article for the suggestion.
Report Post Tip

Game Suggestions
Replying to: HQ Threads, Made + only option
Compose Body:

@Mention Notifications: On More info
How much do you want to tip for this post?

Minimum $20,000

(NaN)
G2
G1
L
H
D
C
Private Conversations
0 PLAYERS IN CHANNEL