May 08 - 15:18:23 |
|
Post Reply | Post new topic | Page: 1 2 3 4 5 [ > - >>> ] |
Public Plea to Honoured Society | Started by: WillHayes on Jan 15, '10 18:09 |
Good afternoon oh Honoured Society. I come to you today with a plea. I feel that there has been enough outcry that something has to be done. And you all have the power in the cities. You and the rest of the Godfathers who haven't been asked to or joined the Honoured Society. So I make this plea, and hope that all Godfathers/mothers hear me out and take this under consideration. The time has come to act. In fact, the time had come a while ago, but there has been no action. So, it's STILL time to act. Recruitment practices must stop. They have caused significant damage to this way of life and I can live with them no more. Unless the Honoured Society acts to make the changes that I shall propose - then I fear that many who have been a part of this life for generations will cease to be a part of this world. There has been recent outcry over this situation. There have been public speeches for months from Gangsters to Dons regarding the deplorable recruiting practices. This is not a new problem, but one that has dirtied these streets for far too long. Issues like sending invites without requests, bullying people to join your crew, and ANY recruiting practices whatsoever should end. There was a time when newly arriving civilians, thieves and gangsters had to prove themselves. They were required to approach a leader and tell their story - how they'd be loyal, and the reasons why they'd make a good addition to a family. Then - well then they'd have to wait while the leader and his upper structure deliberated and made a decision whether that particular person would make a good addition. Why is that not the case anymore? Because there are too many families? That response is one I hear over and over again. And it's crap. Why has the rule prohibiting the shooting of -48 hour gangsters been successful? Because people understand that there are consequences that will follow from violating the rule. The real reason? It would be too much work to legislate. And my response to that is - there are enough people in this world to do the work whereby making it fairly easy to legislate. Note - everybody in this community is well aware when somebody enters this world, and therefore easy enough to determine whether somebody was "recruited" or actually did work to join a family. So - it seems to me that the -48 issue has been resolved. There are very few infractions, and all families make it clear of consequences of killing a -48 gangster. And since that issue is now resolved, the Honoured Society can move on to an issue that has been and will continue to be at the forefront of issues affecting this world. Now, I could go on for hours about the reasons why recruiting is bad, but I hope that most of the people in this community are smart enough to realize why. If not, let me know, and I will gladly return here to offer further explanation. That's my plea. get involved in this issue. Outlaw the practice. And put in place some real consequences, i.e. death for those who recruit. Thank you. And Good Night. |
|
Report Post | Tip |
I don't think it would take all that much to legislate actually Don Hayes. If the leader of every city simply agreed to stop the practice, make it a part of their own city rules for their Family Heads to abide by, then it simply wouldn't happen. This being the case, it takes 8 people to stand up and say "Agreed, no longer will the individuals who dwell in my city approach anyone who is not yet gangster." That's all it would take. Godmother S. Rourke, Godfather Deimne, Consigliere Jelly, Godmother Aurora, Godfather P. Rourke, Godfather Kenobi, Godfather Rourke and Godfather Iota. The eight people who hold the key to the solution to this problem. "Helpful mails" 90% of the time have recruitment as an ulterior motive. Simply, individuals who have not been on the shores for 24 hours should not be approached by family members of any rank. There is no need for them to do so. I specified under 24 hours, and below gangster for a reason. People between 24 and 48 hours, who are of the gangster rank, possibly need the prod from someone to join a family. Aside from that, it's unnecessary and has plagued this shores for too long. |
|
Reply by: Cryptic at Jan 15, '10 19:40 | |
Report Post | Tip |
Here in lies the problem....
|
|
Reply by: Deimne at Jan 15, '10 20:33 | |
Report Post | Tip |
As someone looking on the outside, this almost is perceived to me as the powers that be overtly saying that the Gods as well as City Council have failed in their efforts to keep immigrants within our walls, or, more specifically, not six feet under. |
|
Reply by: Swayzak at Jan 16, '10 01:50 | |
Report Post | Tip |
Hmmm.. I don't know what to really say myself. There is nothing wrong with offering help to our younger jeneration who seek a new life in this thing of ours. Ok yes some people just mail them with..
|
|
Reply by: Mikhail-Faustin at Jan 16, '10 03:10 | |
Report Post | Tip |
With the countless other outcries with regards to this problem I'm not sure it merited yet another one. We have seen this issue crop up a lot in the last few months. I'm sure that in some way or another "The Honoured Society" will look at all possible avenues to stop this kind of thing. |
|
Reply by: TesleR at Jan 16, '10 04:20 | |
Report Post | Tip |
The major problem with this issue is policing it conclusively. Shooting at under 48 hour people, you get a witness statement, a CL gets a memo about it, hell even the newspaper in its Obits column make it perfectly clear that something wrong has occurred. Obviously the system isn't fool proof, there is the potential for a CL to ignore a memo, witness statements can be destroyed. However what we have seen since the Honored Society was set up is a considerable reduction in U48 deaths. Simply playing devils advocate there is no effective way to police the contacting of new people unless you have a massive change of face and decree only certain agreed people are allowed to do this. It just isn't possible. Why is this no doubt people will say: We can't read other peoples mail so we will never be 100% confident that what is forwarded to us is accurate. I am not aware of a personal being issued to a CL or GF when someone asks someone to be their associate, so again this sort of thing is quite easily fabricated. Don't get me wrong I am all for the removal of this whoring process however, I think a draconic rule effectively banning the genuine help to new people entering our world would be detrimental to the objective of increasing the number of mafiosa we have in our world. |
|
Reply by: El_Nino at Jan 16, '10 05:09 | |
Report Post | Tip |
El_Nino I think I want to borrow a bit from your line of thought and try and apply that to Tesler's. Tesler says call them out and let the Whores be defamed publicly. Of course there are some protocols to that, one cant just take center stage and start pointing fingers without some burden of proof, which is probably the biggest reason people can't find a solution to this matter. |
|
Reply by: Fatality at Jan 16, '10 06:05 | |
Report Post | Tip |
"1) How many of their men are dying on a weekly basis over time. Take This should be watched by the leaders anyway. Not just for general member whoring. The levels of members appearing the obits reflect highly on your skills as a leader. Are you able to recruit and teach your members? Are they loyal to you and your rules? Are the lower members of your structure, appointed by yourself, doing of what they ask you and ensuring that your members are being correctly advised? If you are finding yourself having to kill off large numbers of your family weekly then you are doing something considerably wrong. It does not just relate to whoring and although it could be a useful indicator I wouldn't hold too much in relation to whoring. More the skills of the leader. Mind, a bad leader whores, right? |
|
Reply by: bighead at Jan 16, '10 06:16 | |
Report Post | Tip |
|
|
Reply by: Fatality at Jan 16, '10 06:35 | |
Report Post | Tip |
Every opinion I've heard so far is raising points that I agree with and thats exactly where the problem lies. |
|
Reply by: ScipitaRourke at Jan 16, '10 08:21 | |
Report Post | Tip |
I agree with Godmother ScipitaRourke and Godfather Deimne they have both put into words the feelings and sentiments I have on this subject. It is truly something that is such a delicate balance and needs to have concrete boundaries that can be enforceable otherwise the system will fail. I am not going to go on and on here as I believe that ScipitaRourke and Deimne have hit the proverbial nail on the head. |
|
Reply by: Paul_Vidi at Jan 16, '10 08:55 | |
Report Post | Tip |
With respects great godfather Deimne and esteemed godmother Scipita (friends of the cow), I think you are underestimating a key behavioural point. They more you give people, the more they take. We have bred stupidity and laziness into the current group of mafiosos and this has infected our whole way of life. It starts with recruitment practises, this is the front door, the place where they either learn this way of life or take the easy road we are providing them and become pieces of shit who never even speak out or contribute to our headquarters (the majority of them never even come back anyway). |
|
Reply by: GiovanniBovine at Jan 16, '10 09:22 | |
Report Post | Tip |
Remember - you didn't learn to swin because 5 of your friends carried Well Said Cow, friend of _Ragnarok_. Your statment is the truest statement thats been said to this point. |
|
Reply by: _Ragnarok_ at Jan 16, '10 10:06 | |
Report Post | Tip |
The problem with punishing "member-whoring", as Deimne has stated, is that it is exceedingly difficult to pin down an appropriate rule that can be readily enforced. |
|
Reply by: Kates at Jan 16, '10 10:28 | |
Report Post | Tip |
Don Hayes, you make a point that has been raised on numerous occasions but fail to provide a solution... What do you think 'The Honoured Society' should do? I ask this not in disrespect, but in muse as to what your opinion actually is. My standpoint was the same as Deimne -24hours should be enough to allow a thug to make there own mind up and contact a family - however post 24 hours if this has not been done, the member whoring starts again.Problem not resolved. On the flipside though, If you look at some of the new faces, a lot disappear an hour or so after landing on these shores, is that because they have no clue as to who they can or cannot trust, or maybe as to how to approach. so perhaps contact does need to be made by those more experienced in our world? I have recently been criticised (prior to being made - so couldn't do anything anyhow!?) as to the fact that I was offering guided tours - I feel it is our duty to this land to ensure we convert as many people to our trade as possible, regardless of which family they join. Added bonus if they prove themselves to be of suit to join your own. But if there could be guidelines to allow this not to be a bombardment then that would be great... In reality (ooc do the new players want to read the masses of text in the tutorial??) do new people listen to everything that is shouted to them? or do they just want to find things out on there own? If they do, they normally end up dead after 48 hours? This is a delicate balance to juggle without impacting the flow of the boats arriving at these shores? I may be wrong and I may be out of line for questioning , but what would be a resolve that would exclude bombardment, but allow those with no level of knowledge to learn our trade? Because if the new blood ins't taught how to develop then who will be the next generation? your bloodline - fine, but who after that? |
|
Reply by: Mezz at Jan 16, '10 10:32 | |
Report Post | Tip |
Sir Cow, I would like to take this opportunity to speak a counter argument to your points.
|
|
Reply by: -V- at Jan 16, '10 10:41 | |
Report Post | Tip |
Don Bovine hit the nail on the head. |
|
Reply by: Leo at Jan 16, '10 10:45 | |
Report Post | Tip |
|
|
Reply by: Kates at Jan 16, '10 10:47 | |
Report Post | Tip |
I feel these "Help" interactions are absolutely unnecessary. I think it's bullshit, that any of you can hide "member whoring" behind "sending them messages as soon as they leave the boat, wondering if they need help". Honestly, they came here for 1 purpose. To work in the mafia. You don't need to fucking ask them if they know what they're doing. They are given all the tools they need to make an indecent, dishonest living, WITHOUT being harassed by MOB BOSSES and their upper structure. It's fucking embarrassing. |
|
Reply by: Mux at Jan 16, '10 10:54 | |
Report Post | Tip |
Post Reply | View All Threads | Page: 1 2 3 4 5 [ > - >>> ] |
Minimum $20,000