Apr 19 - 17:06:42 |
|
Post Reply | Post new topic | Page: [ <<< - < ] 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 [ > - >>> ] |
The book was better than the movie! | Started by: Elle_E_Ott on Dec 10, '20 00:19 |
Any Farley Mowat book that was remade. That guy had some fantastic books. Lost in the Barrens, the Curse of the Viking Grave, Never Cry Wolf. Canadian classics. In typical Canadian fashion - we don’t do media production very well, although I think our comedy is awkwardly on point. Also - I Hope they serve beer in Hell - tucker Maxx wrote some hilarious books - the movies just didn’t do them justice. |
|
Reply by: Shoresy at May 05, '21 00:14 | |
Report Post | Tip |
Really most movie or show adaptions are different than the books they come from. Whether it’s a drastic change or slight tweaks, the directors and writers seem to make it do there own things. Sometimes it’s for the better but there are a lot of times those few key details they left out ruin it. Especially when you know how it is really supposed to go. | |
Reply by: Magnolia at May 05, '21 13:25 | |
Report Post | Tip |
I do my best to avoid movies/shows based on books. The way the director/producers envisions it never stacks up to what I imagine and once I see it on the screen it's ruined cuz now that's what is imprinted in my head. GoT, The Last Kingdom, The Witcher, even classics like the Sharpe Books by Bernard Cornwell... none of it is as good as they should have been. |
|
Reply by: ZebrishRed at May 05, '21 13:40 | |
Report Post | Tip |
The Alex Rider teen spy series was one of my favourites as a kid! Both movie adaptions sucked complete ass, but recently Prime Video has released a TV show and I found it to be pretty good. I felt it really captured how much of an amateur he was and projected that aesthetic well! |
|
Reply by: James_Alessi at May 05, '21 14:55 | |
Report Post | Tip |
Where do I even begin. Harry Potter, The Hunger Games, every Stephen King book EVER WRITTEN! GAME OF THRONES. And my all time personal favorite.. DRUMROLL! *drumroll begins* AMERICAN GODS. |
|
Reply by: Shadow at May 06, '21 01:10 | |
Report Post | Tip |
The Crow I love the movie and Brandon, nuff said! James Obarr's writing is incredible in the comic book series which I have a 1st prints of :) I think the Comicbooks are superior than the movies but cinematically, Brandon Lee introduced a style of film that made a huge impact at the time. |
|
Reply by: Rembrant at May 16, '21 01:30 | |
Report Post | Tip |
Definitely, Time Travelers Wife! But the movie still the bomb :) |
|
Reply by: Aislin at May 16, '21 03:35 | |
Report Post | Tip |
I Am Legend by Richard Matheson is by far better than any of the adaptations (The Last Man on Earth, Omega Man, and of course I Am Legend). The best adaptation is probably The Last Man on Earth.... The worst ending is definitely I Am Legend. |
|
Reply by: TheLoveliestOfSpikeS at May 16, '21 06:58 | |
Report Post | Tip |
The biggest one for me, was the Vampire Chronicles by Anne Rice. Whilst Interview with the Vampire was fairly close, Queen of the Damned missed alot of what made the book so good, one of the actual main characters to the plot infact. After reading the book, the story felt a hell of a lot more complete. |
|
Reply by: Tyki_Mikk at May 16, '21 08:19 | |
Report Post | Tip |
Although I seem to be one of the few that enjoyed the film Dragon was no where near as good as the books. But tbh it was a very lazy adaption, I mean the most obvious was the fact that Urgals where just men. Despite the fact it was incredibly influenced by Star Wars almost to the point of a carbon copy I really enjoyed the books & wish they'd done a better job then maybe they'd have gotten to make the whole series. |
|
Reply by: HandsBeDroppin at May 16, '21 15:23 | |
Report Post | Tip |
I know for a fact the chronicles of narnia is a much better book then the movies. Far more in depth and detailed. |
|
Reply by: Mihal at May 16, '21 18:49 | |
Report Post | Tip |
Lonesome Dove. I loved the movie, always hard to beat Robert Duvall. But the book was jam packed with so much more info and details. The movie was 6 hours long and still couldn't capture everything that the book had to offer. | |
Reply by: Joe_Campisi at May 17, '21 15:41 | |
Report Post | Tip |
I Am Legend. The movie is considered great by a lot of people however most haven't actually read the novel it's based on which is a shame because it's such a good read. The worst part for me is the ending particularly because the phrase "I am legend" has a much cooler reason behind it as opposed to the silly happy one from the movie. |
|
Reply by: JohnnyLawrence at May 17, '21 21:16 | |
Report Post | Tip |
I really liked the maze runner series of books, but hated the movie when I saw it. Nothing was really how I imagined and couldn't accept it. | |
Reply by: Holden_Macroine at May 21, '21 21:39 | |
Report Post | Tip |
I am an avid reader, I’m guessing it has already been mentioned here (I hope it has!) but Game of Thrones… That TV show ruined the story that was developing in the books, a real shame |
|
Reply by: Grisella at Jun 20, '21 16:08 | |
Report Post | Tip |
Going back to grade school books... But Indian in the Cupboard. Loved the book, but the movie not as much. |
|
Reply by: Keasey- at Jun 20, '21 16:13 | |
Report Post | Tip |
I'm thinking if you compare books to movies you have way to much time on your hands. Read the book Watch the movie Loads of time to help someone make a blanket or plant a garden... both to me seek like a waste of time. Go out and do it.....let someone write a book or do a movie about all of your good deeds. Be a worth while person and be active in your life. |
|
Reply by: SpaceBalls at Jun 21, '21 01:19 | |
Report Post | Tip |
I went and read the Hunger Games recently as was intrigued to how much they had butchered it for the screen. I was both shocked and amazed to discover that the films are pretty much a carbon copy of the books. I don't think they really changed anything to be honest. |
|
Reply by: Qalico at Jun 21, '21 08:05 | |
Report Post | Tip |
Isn't every book better then the movies. For instance the hobbit. That was a oké book of about 100 pages. Now it's 3 movies, how can you make 3 movies about 100 pages. Then you are making things bigger then they are and making things up outside what the story is. This often makes movies bad. | |
Reply by: Madhatter at Jun 21, '21 12:45 | |
Report Post | Tip |
I would agree with you Madhatter in almost all cases. The exception to date though that I have found is - the book thief - pardon the pun. Great book bit dark but you know....didn't want to watch the film but they smashed it too. In tears with both..... |
|
Reply by: hardon-withasuitcase at Jun 21, '21 13:18 | |
Report Post | Tip |
Post Reply | View All Threads | Page: [ <<< - < ] 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 [ > - >>> ] |
Minimum $20,000